Pep Guardiola, one of the most influential managers in modern football, has been at the helm of Manchester City since 2016, revolutionizing the club with his tactical brilliance and an unrelenting pursuit of excellence. Under his guidance, City has dominated English football, securing six Premier League titles and asserting themselves as one of Europe’s elite. However, the 2024/25 season has posed unexpected challenges that lead to an uncomfortable question: Is it time for Guardiola to leave Manchester City?
Despite his history of success, City’s current campaign has been riddled with inconsistency. Sitting fifth in the Premier League table, far from their usual spot at the top or close to it, they have struggled to impose their identity on matches.
Their record of 13 wins, 5 draws, and 7 losses that have aired on Showmax Football paints a troubling picture. The season has been punctuated by moments of brilliance like the 6-0 demolition of Ipswich Town but also alarming setbacks, such as the more recent humbling 5-1 defeat to Arsenal.
At one time last October/November, after a loss to Tottenham Hotspur in the EFL Cup, they went on to lose four consecutive matches across all competitions, including a 4-1 defeat to Sporting Lisbon in the Champions League and Premier League losses to Bournemouth and Brighton. This streak represented their worst run of form since 2006 and was the first time under manager Pep Guardiola that the team experienced four consecutive defeats. This erratic form has fuelled debates over whether Guardiola’s tactical blueprint is still effective.
The downturn is evident. A year ago, City were undisputed champions of England. Now, they are battling just to stay in contention for a top-four finish.
The recent 3-2 Champions League loss to Real Madrid encapsulated their troubles. Erling Haaland delivered a clinical performance, scoring twice, but defensive lapses allowed Madrid to snatch victory through late goals from Brahim Diaz and Jude Bellingham. Such collapses have been a recurring theme this season, exposing vulnerabilities that Guardiola has yet to rectify.
Beyond the pitch, reports suggest Guardiola’s personal life has impacted his mental well-being. The relentless demands of leading a top club like City can take a toll, and questions have emerged about whether he still has the fire to navigate yet another rebuild. Guardiola’s dedication to his craft is unquestionable, but even the best minds need time to recharge.
Guardiola remains one of football’s most innovative thinkers, with an ability to adapt and rebuild that has been proven time and again. His tactical ingenuity has led to an era of sustained success at Manchester City, and his presence ensures continuity for a squad built in his vision. Player development under his watch has been exceptional, with stars like Kevin De Bruyne, Phil Foden, and Bernardo Silva flourishing.
Every great managerial era eventually comes to an end, and sometimes a fresh perspective is needed to reinvigorate a squad. A new voice in the dressing room could provide renewed energy and tactical adjustments that City may benefit from. Furthermore, Guardiola’s mental and physical well-being should be a consideration – he has given everything to City, and stepping away could allow him to regain balance in his life. Long managerial tenures can sometimes lead to diminishing returns, and a change in leadership might bring fresh tactical approaches to keep City ahead.
So, should Guardiola walk away now? It’s a complex decision. His tactical brilliance remains undeniable, and his imprint on Manchester City is indelible. However, if performances continue to falter and his passion wavers, a well-timed exit might be best for both parties.
What do you think? Is it time for Pep Guardiola to turn the page, or does he still have one more great chapter left at Manchester City?
Stream every Premier League match on Showmax Premier League mobile for as low as N3,200. Sign up on Showmax.
